THE ENEMY IS US
THERE is an interesting aspect to the “torture debate,” which I wish to comment on, and insightfully so. By this I mean the various opinions at what should be done, and how, to the prisoners of (not quite a) war captured over there in Asia. This debate involves whether these guys should be given any legal rights.
The Liberals tend to argue that they
should be given every legal protection, up to everything “owed” to American
citizens. They also tend to argue
that the reason for this position is that anything else is not in keeping with
the “American character.” Usually,
they add something like “we” (i.e. Americans) have such a value system that
that such full legal protection is mandated.
Really? How can anyone determine what is consistent with THE American character? Americans killed Indians, sometimes without just cause. Americans stole about one third of the country from Mexico. Americans stole Cuba from Spain, for no good reason. America sustained legal slavery for quite a time. On the other hand, of course, America has done a lot of good things. For example, it has provided unmatched economic opportunity, and a lot of personal freedom, to many. And, for a long time, it kept women from voting.
My point is that, like every other nation, America has done lots of good things as well as many bad things. So which parts of its history are used to identify what is in keeping with American-ism? If only the better parts are used, and the rest considered aberrations, then America would be Heaven on Earth, and its citizens would be angels.
But then if only the good actions of a human are counted then even Badass Obama would be considered to be no worse than Charles Manson.
Be a true American, or a false one
(if this is what you want), by subscribing to the A&E.
